15 November 2026
Manila set out to close a 24-year-old promise at the 49th ASEAN Summit. It is handing Singapore a text that is four-fifths agreed, with the three hardest questions still open. Carla Teng-Westergaard reports in Manila.
Philippines' Foreign Affairs Secretary Ma Theresa Lazaro's press briefing on Sunday, November 15 at the ASEAN International Media Centre.
For the Philippines, this summit was meant to be the moment a two-decade-old promise finally became a document. Instead, Foreign Affairs Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro came to the briefing room on Sunday (Nov. 15) with a number: 80 percent.
"We are pleased to report the substantial completion of the negotiations on the ASEAN-China Code of Conduct," Lazaro told reporters, reading from the chair's briefing. The parties to the 2002 Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea (DOC), she said, "have reached provisional agreement on about 80% of the paragraphs of the draft COC." The negotiators, she added, "now enter their final phase."
That final phase will not happen under Manila. With the Philippine chairmanship ending, Lazaro said the almost-finished text would go to Singapore, which chairs ASEAN in 2027. The three issues the parties have still not settled go with it, and one of them is whether the code will be legally binding at all.
The result falls short of the goal Manila set itself. In February, Lazaro said the Philippines would try to conclude the code this year, in line with a 2023 mandate from ASEAN and Chinese foreign ministers to finish within three years. "It is… about time to finish," she said then.
Lazaro presented the 80 percent figure as an achievement of the Philippine chairmanship. Before Manila took over the process, she said, the draft was "only about 50% perhaps." Now it was at 80 percent, "and even moving."
On the Philippines' recommendation as chair, the parties held nine rounds of negotiations and two senior officials' meetings in 2026, which she said amounted to a monthly meeting of negotiators. Malaysia and China formally co-chair the talks, Lazaro noted, "but it is the Philippines' chair who has been shepherding the whole process." (The Associated Press, citing three senior Southeast Asian diplomats, counted at least 10 major rounds this year, jointly led by China and Malaysia, which coordinates ASEAN's relations with Beijing.)
Of the four "milestone" issues that have defined the endgame, only one is settled: how the new code relates to the 2002 declaration. Under the provisional agreement, the DOC is the foundation of the code, the code is consistent with and builds on the DOC's principles, and the code sets out "more effective and substantive provisions to guide the conduct of the parties in the South China Sea."
The chair's briefing also recorded several other points of agreement:
A platform for cooperation. Besides guiding conduct, the code will serve as a platform for practical maritime cooperation, carried out on a voluntary basis and in accordance with the 1982 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).
Managing disputes, not settling them. "The COC is intended to serve as a mechanism for the constructive management of differences at sea and not to settle disputes," Lazaro read.
Familiar commitments. The parties reaffirmed peaceful settlement of disputes under international law, including UNCLOS. They also reaffirmed freedom of navigation and overflight, and preventing and managing incidents at sea.
Asked whether the code would protect the rights of countries outside ASEAN, Lazaro said yes, and that this had been the Philippine position "from the very start." She also stressed that the code is a regional instrument and does not cover bilateral disputes. "This is region-wide. It's ASEAN. It's 10 plus China," she said.
Despite not achieving its goal of securing a Code of Conduct under its chairmanship, the Philippines, according to Lazaro, still takes pride in the progress made.
The hard part is what remains. "The legally binding nature of the code — this is still pending," Lazaro said. "The three are still pending."
She did not list the other two remaining milestones on Sunday. In July, however, she identified the four as the code's relationship to the DOC, whether it is legally binding, its geographic scope, and the definition of self-restraint, according to the Philippine News Agency and GMA News.
Asked what had held the talks back, Lazaro pointed to the size of the table rather than to any outside party. "Negotiations are negotiations are negotiations," she said. "The 10 ASEAN countries plus China have, of course, different views." A binding document would also need to go through ratification in some member states, she added. "I think there was not enough time. If we were given probably another five to six months, I think we can finish that."
She would not go into the substance of the disputed clauses. Asked whether the agreed text covers military exercises by third parties such as the United States, or defines the "status quo" at sea, she said the negotiators were still handling those questions and that she did not have the document in front of her. "It's not finished yet. So let's wait."
The code has been promised for almost a quarter-century. ASEAN and China signed the DOC in Phnom Penh on Nov. 4, 2002. It was a non-binding political declaration, watered down from the code that was originally being negotiated. In it, the parties undertook to work toward an eventual code on the basis of consensus, a commitment Lazaro recalled on Sunday.
Formal consultations on the code did not begin until September 2013. A framework followed in August 2017, and a single draft negotiating text in August 2018. Later that year, the parties set themselves three years, starting in 2019, to finish. They missed that deadline.
In between came the July 12, 2016, award of an arbitral tribunal in the case the Philippines brought under UNCLOS. The tribunal rejected the legal basis of Beijing's sweeping historic claims. China rejects the ruling and still claims jurisdiction over nearly all of the sea. The Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei and Indonesia also have overlapping claims or maritime entitlements in the area.
The current push dates to July 13, 2023. In Jakarta, ASEAN foreign ministers and China's top diplomat Wang Yi adopted guidelines for accelerating the talks. Indonesia's foreign ministry described the guidelines as setting an aspiration to finish in three years or less. That three-year window closes this year, under the Philippine chairmanship.
Infographics: AMC
The talks took place against a hostile backdrop at sea and in the region's capitals. China Coast Guard vessels have repeatedly used water cannon on Philippine ships. In October, according to Al Jazeera, China's ambassador to Manila, Jing Quan, said Beijing could easily win if it used force. President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. said the remark sounded like a threat, and some Philippine senators called for the envoy to be expelled. Chinese Premier Li Qiang is attending the leaders' summit in Manila.
Thitinan Pongsudhirak, a Thai political scientist at Chulalongkorn University and Asia New Zealand Foundation's honorary adviser says the South China Sea shows that ASEAN has no common position toward outside powers. In a commentary published as leaders gathered in Manila, he wrote that China takes advantage of members' differing views of it to pursue its maritime claims. That leaves the Philippines exposed, he argued, especially with Washington less predictable under President Donald Trump.
Thitinan also questioned how much a finished code would change at sea. "A text without teeth will not do much to stop China's incursions," he wrote. He sees Singapore's 2027 chairmanship as a chance for reform. One of his proposals is to extend the "ASEAN Minus X" formula used in economic integration, which lets willing members move ahead without waiting for the rest, to coalitions on issues such as maritime security.
Collin Koh, a senior fellow at Singapore's S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies, makes a similar point. He argues that whether the code is legally binding matters little unless the parties also agree on how compliance will be checked and enforced.
Aries Arugay, a political scientist at the University of the Philippines, told Al Jazeera that the chair was in a no-win position: "If you get a good document, you'll be accused of railroading." Chinese scholars remain wary of a binding code. Ding Duo of China's National Institute for South China Sea Studies told the South China Morning Post that China, the Philippines and Vietnam would all reject a binding version if it involved clarifying maritime rights.
Lazaro was asked whether the Philippines could now say it had met one of its main goals as chair. She drew a line between progress and completion. "We can say that we've reached our ultimate goal in concluding the negotiations once it has been finalized," she said. "Evidently, there's no conclusion yet." Still, she called the code "something that we can be proud of," the result of "a lot of hard work."
On the remaining milestones, she said: "They call them milestones because it's really very important issues." The DOC question showed that agreement was possible, she said, so "it's a matter of time. And I trust that Singapore will be able to finish the discussions."
Singapore is not a claimant in the South China Sea.
Singapore is not a claimant in the South China Sea disputes. However, developments in the region affect every country in the bloc. According to Lazaro, the Code of Conduct (COC) also takes into account the rights and interests of third parties, including regional countries such as Singapore.
The parties' final pledge in the chair's briefing was to keep working toward "an effective and substantive code of conduct at the earliest possible time." The phrase has appeared in ASEAN statements for years. Whether Singapore can turn it into a signed text depends on the three issues Manila could not close: whether the code is binding, what waters it covers, and what self-restraint actually requires.
-Asia Media Centre