20 November 2026
Trump, Xi and Putin met together for the first time at APEC. New Zealand wasn’t in the room, but the small print matters to a country that sells three-quarters of its exports to this part of the world. Graeme Acton reports from Shenzhen.
There is a long tradition of three leaders sitting down to carve up the world. In 1945, Yalta had a Crimean palace and a bleak February. China’s southern metropolis Shenzhen had a round table, with a bowl of pink orchids in the middle, apparently serving as the demilitarised zone.
On Thursday, Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin held their first-ever three-way sit-down at the Qilin Shanzhuang State Residence, on the sidelines of APEC. After some 90 minutes, they emerged with a four-point “Declaration towards Peace”: more oil and refined fuel, talks to reduce nuclear risk, unspecified reform of the United Nations, and a stern word about the International Criminal Court overreaching its jurisdiction. That’s the same Court with a current warrant for the arrest of the Russian President.
Putin, Xi and Trump at the trilateral meeting at the Qilin Shanzhuang State Residence, Shenzhen, 19 November 2026. Photo: pool/AFP
What the Shenzhen declaration left out was obvious. No mention of Russia’s war in Ukraine. No mention of the US-led war in Iran. Nothing on Taiwan. Ruby Osman, of the Tony Blair Institute, summed up Beijing’s approach neatly: Xi wanted to be “the adult in the room”. In a room containing a nuclear briefcase that is a competitive field, and Russian state TV helpfully filmed the officer carrying it.
The mood music was warm. Putin called Xi “dear friend”. Trump called Putin “my friend” and recalled their “great relationship for many years”. On his way out Putin said he hadn’t expected things to go so well, and when a Moscow reporter asked whether this was “Yalta 2.0”, Putin nodded. Beijing’s state media Xinhua, perhaps wisely, preferred the phrase “positive and fruitful”.
Analysts were less rapturous. Many judged the visuals to perhaps be the only lasting impression, a summit short on substance. That suits a US president fresh from a midterm caning and keen on pageantry. Back home in Washington , Republican Senator John Curtis pointedly noted that Putin and Xi “are not our friends”, and nine Democratic senators warned in writing against trading security for “photo opportunities”.
Trump told Fox News the meeting was “12 out of 10”, claiming Putin is ready to make a Ukraine deal. Putin, for his part, insisted it was “serious joint work”, although the summit produced no ceasefire, no new sanctions, no commitment from Putin and no visible shift in Moscow’s position.
This week at APEC in Shenzhen, many commentators have argued that right now is not the best time for a genuine great-power conversation, but that simply getting the three leaders in the room widened what is diplomatically possible in future.
There is plenty to potentially talk about of course : calm on the Korean Peninsula, limits on strikes on energy infrastructure in Ukraine, pressure on Tehran to reopen the Strait of Hormuz, not to mention dealing with new arms control agreements now the old START deal has expired. Of that list, only the nuclear issue was mentioned, in the somewhat tired (but accurate) pledge that nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought. It is exactly the sentiment New Zealand has championed since it legislated its nuclear-free status nearly forty years ago.
So where does a country of five million, a long way from Shenzhen, fit in? Caretaker Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Trade Minister Todd McClay were in town for APEC proper, under the caretaker convention, NZ diplomacy’s equivalent of house-sitting. Both attended the Welcome Banquet earlier in the week, and flew the flag in meetings across the business end of the summit.
It was a flying visit but an important one - APEC economies buy about 75 percent of New Zealand’s exports, and host China is our biggest trading partner.
Against that backdrop, yesterday’s “Shenzhen Outlook” is the document of interest. It endorses a better trade and investment environment, and the flow of energy and “other essential goods”. But it makes no mention of the World Trade Organization or the multilateral trading system, and rare earths, the biggest sore point between Washington and Beijing, are also absent. For an exporter whose trade strategy relies on the rulebook, it could appear a bit once-over-lightly.
The same goes for the ICC and UN points. Three permanent Security Council members agreeing (for the hundredth time) that the UN needs reform, without saying exactly what kind. Former NZ PM Peter Fraser spent 1945 at San Francisco arguing against the great-power veto, and his view that smaller countries like New Zealand are entitled to more than footnotes, has not aged.
On the ICC -a trilateral that warns against “jurisdiction abuse” by international courts, while one of its members is subject to an ICC arrest warrant, struggles to hold the line for the rules-based order New Zealand promotes so hard.
There is one deliverable with plausible impact in Aotearoa: the pledge to increase oil and refined fuel supply. If it translates into real barrels, and if Iran reopens Hormuz, which Trump says he and Xi agree on, then Kiwi motorists might feel it before the diplomats do. That would be the summit’s most tangible legacy.
There was some commentary around before the meeting about it being the second “Yalta”, the occasion involving allied leaders Churchill, Stalin and Roosevelt in 1945 to look at the carve up following the then inevitable defeat of Nazi Germany.
A good headline perhaps, and certainly the optics were similar. The irony of course is that Yalta is in Crimea – currently occupied by Russia in its war against Ukraine.
But whether a trilateral that agreed on oil, nukes and the shortcomings of courts becomes any sort of precedent depends on whether something tangible follows the photographs. In the meantime, New Zealand’s task is the same as ever: read the fine print, keep making friends and doing deals in every Asian capital.
Asia Media Centre