News

Timeline:ThedebatearoundPRCinfluenceinNZandAustralia


China’s influence in Australia and New Zealand politics proved one of 2017’s most contentious foreign affairs issues in both countries. Debate is likely to continue into 2018. 

The Asia Media Centre has collated major reports, articles and blogs on the topic, highlighting how the issue has been covered so far. This page will be updated as required. 

Click to jump to section:


Emergence of the debate in Australia

While the debate over Chinese influence in Australian politics built over some years, the issue came to mainstream attention after allegations of misconduct by Labor politician Sam Dastyari over links with Chinese donors. The story gained traction after an ABC Four Corners episode that examined Chinese Communist Party (CCP) influence in Australian politics.

  • 2014

    • Jun 13: John Fitzgerald: Why values matter in Australia’s relationship with China (The ASAN Forum)  
  • 2016

    • Aug 31: Senator Sam Dastyari under fire after Chinese donor foots travel allowance bill overspend (ABC News)
  • 2017

    • Jun 5: Four Corners – Power and Influence (ABC News
    • Jun 9: Bates Gill and Linda Jakobson: China Matters: Getting it right for Australia (China Policy Institute)
    • Oct: The Giant Awakens: A collection of insights into Chinese government influence in Australia (Vision Times)
    • Nov 28: Clive Hamilton: The real reason you won’t be reading my new book on China anytime soon (Sydney Morning Herald)
    • Nov 29: Sam Dastyari quits Federal Parliament (ABC News
    • Nov 30: Bill Shorten dumps Sam Dastyari from Senate job (ABC News
    • Dec 15: Saying the unsayable in Australia’s relations with China (The Interpreter)

Back to top 


Shift to New Zealand

In New Zealand, two events brought the issue of China’s international influence into the media spotlight: Allegations over the background of National Party MP Yang Jian; and the release of a report by University of Canterbury professor Anne-Marie Brady highlighting Chinese Communist Party “united front” activities.

  • 2017

    •  Jul 17: Simon Draper: Australia’s Asia debate worryingly polarising (Stuff
    • Sep 13: National MP: I taught Chinese spies (Newsroom
    • Sep 13: China-born New Zealand MP probed by spy agency (Financial Times; paywall)
    • Sep 13: National: no idea of SIS inquiry into Yang (Newsroom)
    • Sep 14: China’s soft power push (Newsroom)
    • Sep 14: Winston Peters brings dog whistle to Dunedin, calls for inquiry into Jian Yang’s spy links (Stuff)
    • Sep 18: Anne-Marie Brady: Magic Weapons: China’s political influence activities under Xi Jinping (Wilson Centre; PDF)
    • Sep 20: Revealed: China’s network of influence in New Zealand (NZ Herald)
    • Sep 20: The political cone of silence, with slurs (Croaking Cassandra)
    • Sep 21: New Zealand: United Frontlings always win (Jichang lulu
    • Sep 23: Charles Finny: Time for NZ political parties to take the migrant vote seriously (Asia Media Centre)
    • Sep 28: Peters won’t let Yang ‘allegations’ slide (Newsroom)
    • Oct 19: OIA documents confirm National MP Jian Yang did not disclose military intelligence links (NZ Herald)
    • Oct 31: Jian Yang’s past ‘a matter for him’ – Bill English (Radio NZ)
    • Nov 14: Anne-Marie Brady: Looking for Points in Common While Facing Up to Differences – A New Model for New Zealand-China Relations (Canterbury.ac.nz; PDF) 
    • Dec 4: China’s Political Influence Activities: A Conversation with Anne-Marie Brady (ChinaPower)
    • Dec 5: NZ mayors talk up China ties (Newsroom
    • Dec 5: Remember Janis Joplin before judging China too harshly, says Winston Peters (NZ Herald
    • Dec 6: Geremie R Barmé: Reaching Forty-five (China Heritage
    • Dec 6: Morning Report: Surprise that NZ hasn’t acted earlier on foreign influence (Radio NZ)
    • Dec 7: PM Jacinda Ardern discounts Chinese influence (NZ Herald
    • Dec 7: Sir Don McKinnon: Expanding relationship with China in New Zealand’s interests (NZ Herald)
    • Dec 12: Political Roundup by Bryce Edwards: China’s ‘magic weapons’ in NZ (NZ Herald)
    • Dec 13: GCSB and SIS table China’s influence at Five Eyes meeting (NZ Herald
    • Dec 14: Pattrick Smellie: Nations question terms of their friendship with China (Stuff)
    • Dec 19: Simon Chapple: China is seeking an insidious influence in New Zealand (NZ Herald
    • Dec 19: Bonnie Glaser: Countries need to be clear-eyed about China (Asia Media Centre
    • Dec 20: MP Yang lobbied ministers to overturn Security Intelligence Service block (NZ Herald)  

Back to top 


Commentary on media coverage 

Questions have been raised about who has been willing to comment on the story in mainstream media. In light of Professor Anne-Marie Brady’s report, there has also been coverage of the level of independence in Chinese-language media in New Zealand. English-language media in the PRC criticised Australian media outlets, while the spokesperson of the Chinese Embassy in Australia called the reports fabricated.

Back to top


Reactions from China

News and commentary from English-language press in China has been highly critical of the coverage of the issue in Australasia. Media outlets have covered official denials of influence claims, while some commentators have called the influence claims fake and likened them to McCarthyism.

  • 2017

    • Nov 30: Opinion: Is a new kind of McCarthyism emerging in Australia? (Global Times)
    • Dec 8: Commentary: It’s time for Australia to decide what kind of relationship it wants with China (Xinhua)
    • Dec 12: Opinion: Australia must be realistic in dealing with China (People’s Daily Online)
    • Dec 12: Opinion: West suspicion of China infiltration absurd (Global Times)
    • Dec 14: Summoning of Aussie ambassador serves as warning to anti-China trend: experts (Global Times)
    • Dec 30: Opinion: Mirror mirror on the wall, who is the sharpest of them all? (Global Times)

Back to top


International views

The international media primarily focused on Australia, but the Yang Jian story and report by University of Canterbury Professor Anne-Marie Brady called attention to New Zealand. New Zealand at times appears as a contrast to Australia, or is otherwise used as an example of influence claims outside Australia.

  • 2018

    • Jan 4: A look at China’s pervasive attempts to exert its influence around the world (LA Times)
  • 2017

    • Sep 20: Chinese influence and intelligence activities: A few notes (The Scholar’s Stage)
    • Sep 23: Spies and a magic weapon: Why are Australia, NZ so suspicious of China? (South China Morning Post
    • Oct 4: A New Zealand lawmaker’s spy-linked past raises alarms on China’s reach (New York Times
    • Dec 13: Australia, New Zealand face China’s influence (CFR.org)
    • Dec 13: The Long Arm of China: Exporting authoritarianism with Chinese characteristics (CECC.govYouTube)
    • Dec 14: Analysis: China’s ‘long arm’ of influence stretches ever further (Washington Post)

Back to top

– Asia Media Centre